andreil soulmate au where the name on neil’s arm is burned off of him before he’s old enough to read. the name on andrew’s, covered in scars, is the name neil was born with, and everything’s a mess (because it’s andrew and neil, of course it is)
neil
doesn’t see andrew’s mark for the longest time and when he does he almost has a fucking heart attack. andrew thinks he’s freaking out about the scars for a second and then he sees where Neil’s looking, at those black letters on pale skin, and that’s when he starts to guess about neil, even if it takes a while to get confirmationlater on they get tattoos together. neil gets andrew’s name redone because that should’ve been his, he should’ve had that name with him his whole life, and andrew gets “nathaniel wesninski” covered because that’s not who neil is anymore. on his other arm he gets neil’s name, first middle last. the tattoo artist is stupid enough to assume they’re some non-bonded couple that won’t really last, asking them over and over if they’re sure. he tries to joke with neil about stealing andrew away from his real soulmate and neil gives him a sharp smile and tells him that nathaniel wesninski is dead.
(neil’s secretly fucked up in love over the fact that andrew got his tattoo redone with neil’s permanent name because no one else is really gonna see it, since andrew never wears short sleeves. but andrew did it anyway because he sees the way neil freezes every time he sees his old name)
the minyard josten rivalry lasts all of about 45 seconds before someone’s like “yo josten has andrew’s name on his fucking arm” (they don’t see andrew’s so they still have to speculate a little but neil doesn’t hide his. he doesn’t go around flaunting it either, but he doesn’t exactly make it hard on them)
this is great and i love it but counterpoint about the minyard-josten rivalry: both neil and andrew keep making up shit about the tattoos to the point of absurdity
“we don’t all have a perfect memory. i got his name tattooed to remind myself that i hate him even when i can’t see him” – neil
“he’s so stupid. he got my name tattooed to commemorate our five year rivals anniversary and forgot that soul marks are a thing” – andrew
“andrew has mine so i figured it would be rude not to match” – neil
“josten doesn’t even drink but sometimes he gets drunk on his own stupidity and things like that happen” – andrew
“we got married and i would lose all and any rings so i got this” – neil
“josten can’t half-ass anything, i once told him that i didn’t hate him that much and he went and got a fucking tattoo of my name” – andrew
“i killed his soulmate and i didn’t have one to begin with so we figured we’d just get together” – neil
“he killed my soulmate and it was really hot so i figured why not” – andrew
reporter: “andrew what’s your tattoo say?” andrew, deadpan: “i don’t have arms”